BeStock  
Markets › Compare › MCY vs SIGI

MCY vs SIGI

Side-by-side comparison of price performance, valuation, growth, profitability, analyst targets and technical trend.

vsvs
MCY · Mercury General$81.43 ▼ 1.40%
SIGI · Selective Insurance$103.25 ▲ 0.53%

One year, rebased to 100

Each line starts at 100 so growth is directly comparable

87100112125138Nov 24, '25May 21, '26Nov 16, '26
  • MCY -6.7%
  • SIGI +34.9%

Head to head

MetricMCYSIGI
Price$81.43$103.25
Change today▼ 1.40%▲ 0.53%
Market cap$4.51B$6.09B
Return, 3 months-23.1%+13.1%
Return, year to date-12.6%+25.2%
Return, 1 year-9.9%+34.7%
P/E (TTM)7.012.4
P/B1.61.9
P/E percentile vs own 5y58th21st
Dividend yield1.56%1.67%
Revenue growth (YoY, latest qtr)-12.8%-2.5%
Net profit growth (YoY)-104.9%+11.5%
Gross margin––
Operating margin––
Net margin10.5%9.2%
Return on equity25.5%15.4%
Analyst target vs. price–-0.7%
Analyst buy share–33%
RSI (14)2570
30-day volatility49.0%24.5%
Max drawdown, 1 year-26.5%-17.8%
Trend readStrong downtrendStrong uptrend
Analyst consensus–Hold

Green cells mark the best value in each row where "better" is clear-cut (lower P/E, higher margin). That is a reading of the numbers, not a recommendation. Financials are in each company's reporting currency.

What the numbers say

  • SIGI is the largest of the group by market value.
  • SIGI has returned the most over the past year.
  • MCY carries the lowest trailing P/E.
  • SIGI pays the highest dividend yield.
  • SIGI is growing revenue fastest.
  • MCY keeps the most profit per dollar of sales.
  • SIGI has been the calmest stock over the last 30 days.

Go deeper

Scroll to Top